Elastic and Inelastic Collisions
Two snooker balls click and spring apart. A car folds itself around a lamp-post and stops dead. A
lump of clay slaps into a wall and just… sticks. All three are collisions — bodies
meeting and pushing on each other for a fleeting instant — yet they end in wildly different ways. The
balls keep almost all their bounce; the car keeps none; the clay keeps none and travels on
stuck to whatever it hit.
There is one thing every isolated collision has in common, and one thing that separates them. The
shared law is the conservation
of momentum: with no outside forces, the total momentum after equals the total momentum
before, always. What differs is what happens to the
kinetic energy — and that single question,
"was the kinetic energy kept or lost?", is what sorts every collision into elastic or
inelastic.
Momentum always survives — kinetic energy is the question
Take two bodies of mass m_1, m_2 approaching with velocities
u_1, u_2 and leaving with velocities v_1, v_2.
Because the system is isolated, momentum is conserved in every case:
m_1 u_1 + m_2 u_2 = m_1 v_1 + m_2 v_2.
This single equation is true whether the bodies bounce, crumple, or stick. But it is only
one equation, and after a collision there are usually two unknown velocities — so
on its own it is not enough to solve everything. The extra information comes from the kinetic energy,
and that is exactly where collisions split into two families.
-
In an elastic collision the total kinetic energy is also conserved. Nothing
is lost to heat, sound or squashing — the store of motion is handed over intact.
\tfrac12 m_1 u_1^2 + \tfrac12 m_2 u_2^2 = \tfrac12 m_1 v_1^2 + \tfrac12 m_2 v_2^2.
Perfectly elastic collisions are an idealisation, but some come astonishingly close: gas molecules,
many subatomic and nuclear collisions, and — near enough for a school problem — hard steel ball
bearings or snooker balls.
-
In an inelastic collision momentum is still conserved, but kinetic energy is
not — some of it is turned into heat, sound and the permanent work of bending metal or
squashing clay. Most everyday collisions are inelastic. The extreme case, where the bodies
stick together and move off as one, is called perfectly inelastic,
and it loses the most kinetic energy that momentum conservation will allow.
What is conserved in a collision
For two bodies colliding in an isolated system:
-
Momentum is always conserved:
m_1 u_1 + m_2 u_2 = m_1 v_1 + m_2 v_2 — in every collision, elastic or
not.
-
Kinetic energy is conserved only if the collision is elastic:
\sum \tfrac12 m u^2 = \sum \tfrac12 m v^2. If it is inelastic, the total
kinetic energy afterwards is less than before.
-
A perfectly inelastic collision is one in which the bodies join and move with a
single common velocity v = \dfrac{m_1 u_1 + m_2 u_2}{m_1 + m_2} — the
maximum possible loss of kinetic energy.
These four traps catch almost everyone learning collisions:
-
Momentum is conserved in every collision; kinetic energy is not. Do not
assume both are conserved. Reach for the kinetic-energy equation only when you are told (or
can show) the collision is elastic — otherwise it simply isn't true.
-
"Perfectly inelastic" does not mean the momentum vanishes. It means the bodies
stick together. Their combined momentum is exactly the momentum they had before — it is the
kinetic energy that takes the biggest hit, not the momentum.
-
The lost kinetic energy is not destroyed. Energy is always conserved overall; the
"missing" kinetic energy has become heat, sound and the work done deforming the bodies. It left the
kinetic store, it did not leave the universe.
-
Velocity has a direction — mind the signs. In a head-on collision one body's
velocity is negative. Put the minus sign into m u and
\tfrac12 m u^2 correctly (the square kills the sign in the energy, but
never in the momentum).
Perfectly inelastic: worked example (they stick together)
A 1200\ \text{kg} car travelling at 15\ \text{m/s}
runs into the back of a stationary 800\ \text{kg} car; their bumpers lock and
they move off together. Find (a) their common velocity and (b) the kinetic energy lost.
Step 1 — conserve momentum. Only the first car is moving, so
u_2 = 0. They stick, so afterwards both share one velocity
v:
m_1 u_1 + m_2 u_2 = (m_1 + m_2)\,v \;\Rightarrow\; 1200 \times 15 + 0 = (1200 + 800)\,v.
18\,000 = 2000\,v \;\Rightarrow\; v = 9\ \text{m/s}.
Step 2 — kinetic energy before.
E_k^{\text{before}} = \tfrac12 \times 1200 \times 15^2 + 0 = \tfrac12 \times 1200 \times 225 = 135\,000\ \text{J} = 135\ \text{kJ}.
Step 3 — kinetic energy after (one lump of 2000\ \text{kg}
moving at 9\ \text{m/s}):
E_k^{\text{after}} = \tfrac12 \times 2000 \times 9^2 = \tfrac12 \times 2000 \times 81 = 81\,000\ \text{J} = 81\ \text{kJ}.
Step 4 — the loss.
\Delta E_k = 135 - 81 = 54\ \text{kJ lost}.
Forty per cent of the kinetic energy has gone — into crumpled metal, a bang, and warmth. Momentum, in
contrast, is untouched: 2000 \times 9 = 18\,000\ \text{kg·m/s}, exactly what
the moving car brought with it.
Elastic: worked example (the bounce that keeps its energy)
A 2\ \text{kg} ball moving at 3\ \text{m/s}
strikes a stationary 1\ \text{kg} ball head-on in a perfectly elastic
collision. Find both velocities afterwards.
Now we have two conservation laws — momentum and kinetic energy — so two equations for the two
unknowns v_1, v_2:
2(3) + 1(0) = 2 v_1 + 1 v_2 \;\Rightarrow\; 6 = 2 v_1 + v_2,
\tfrac12 (2)(3^2) = \tfrac12 (2) v_1^2 + \tfrac12 (1) v_2^2 \;\Rightarrow\; 9 = v_1^2 + \tfrac12 v_2^2.
Solving the pair (the trivial "no collision" answer v_1 = 3,\ v_2 = 0 is
rejected) gives
v_1 = 1\ \text{m/s}, \qquad v_2 = 4\ \text{m/s}.
Check both laws. Momentum: 2(1) + 1(4) = 6 ✓. Kinetic
energy: \tfrac12(2)(1^2) + \tfrac12(1)(4^2) = 1 + 8 = 9\ \text{J} ✓ — every
joule accounted for, so the collision really is elastic.
For a perfectly elastic head-on collision between two equal masses, the algebra
collapses to a beautiful result: the two bodies simply exchange velocities.
v_1 = u_2, \qquad v_2 = u_1.
A moving ball striking an identical stationary one stops dead and sends the target off at its own
former speed — the trick behind every Newton's cradle.
Is this collision elastic? Check the kinetic energy
Sometimes you are handed all four velocities and asked which kind of collision it was. The recipe is
simple: momentum will balance either way, so the test is the kinetic energy — work
out the total before and after and compare.
A 4\ \text{kg} trolley moving at 5\ \text{m/s}
hits a stationary 4\ \text{kg} trolley. Afterwards the first moves at
1\ \text{m/s} and the second at 4\ \text{m/s}
(same direction). Elastic or inelastic?
Momentum check first (it must balance for the data to be valid):
4(5) = 20 before, 4(1) + 4(4) = 20 after ✓.
Now the kinetic energy:
E_k^{\text{before}} = \tfrac12(4)(5^2) = 50\ \text{J},
E_k^{\text{after}} = \tfrac12(4)(1^2) + \tfrac12(4)(4^2) = 2 + 32 = 34\ \text{J}.
Kinetic energy has fallen from 50\ \text{J} to
34\ \text{J} — a loss of 16\ \text{J}. So although
momentum is perfectly conserved, this collision is inelastic. Had the two totals been
equal, it would have been elastic.
Explosions: a collision run backwards
An explosion is the mirror image of a perfectly inelastic collision. There, two bodies
merge and lose kinetic energy; here, one body flies apart and gains kinetic energy —
released from a chemical, elastic or nuclear store inside it. Yet momentum is still conserved: if the
object started at rest, the total momentum was zero, so the fragments must fly off with momenta that
cancel exactly.
A stationary 3\ \text{kg} firework bursts into a
1\ \text{kg} piece and a 2\ \text{kg} piece. The
light piece shoots off at 4\ \text{m/s}. How fast, and which way, does the
heavy piece go?
0 = m_1 v_1 + m_2 v_2 \;\Rightarrow\; 0 = 1(4) + 2 v_2 \;\Rightarrow\; v_2 = -2\ \text{m/s}.
The minus sign says the 2\ \text{kg} piece flies off at
2\ \text{m/s} in the opposite direction — a small heavy chunk kicking
back against a light fast one, just like a gun recoiling against its bullet. The kinetic energy,
meanwhile, has climbed from nothing to
\tfrac12(1)(4^2) + \tfrac12(2)(2^2) = 8 + 4 = 12\ \text{J}, drawn straight from
the gunpowder. Momentum conserved; kinetic energy created from a store — the reverse of a crash.
Play with a collision
Set the mass and starting velocity of each cart, then pick the collision type. The
figure works out the velocities after the collision (momentum is always conserved) and draws a
bar for the total kinetic energy before and after. Watch the key pattern: switching from
elastic to inelastic to stick together leaves the momentum untouched but
makes the "after" energy bar shrink further and further — with the perfectly inelastic case losing the
most.
It feels backwards, but a car is deliberately built to crumple. A rigid car would rebound
from a wall almost elastically, reversing your velocity and subjecting you to a huge, sudden change in
momentum in a tiny time — a brutal force. A crumple zone turns the crash into a very
inelastic one: the folding metal soaks up the kinetic energy as heat and deformation, and it
spreads the change in momentum over a longer time, so the force on the passengers drops. The same
logic runs through airbags, crash mats, cricketers drawing their hands back, and a boxer "rolling"
with a punch. Meanwhile a Newton's cradle shows off the opposite ideal: its hardened
steel balls collide almost perfectly elastically, so the click of energy passes clean through the row
and one ball swings up on the far side — over and over, losing only the little that leaks away as
sound and warmth.