When a Limit Doesn't Exist
A limit is a promise: as x approaches
c, the outputs settle on one number
L. Sometimes that promise can't be kept, and we say the
limit does not exist (often written DNE). There are
three classic ways it fails.
- A jump — the two sides head to different heights.
- Blowing up — the outputs run off to \pm\infty.
- Wild oscillation — the outputs never settle at all.
Each builds on one-sided
limits: a two-sided limit exists only when both sides agree on a single,
finite value.
1. The jump
We met this in one-sided limits. The function steps from one height to another at
x = c:
\lim_{x \to c^-} f(x) \ne \lim_{x \to c^+} f(x).
Both one-sided limits exist, but they disagree — so the two-sided limit DNE.
2. Blowing up to infinity
Near a vertical asymptote the outputs grow without bound. Take
f(x) = \frac{1}{x^2}.
As x \to 0 from either side, the values shoot up toward
+\infty. There is no finite L to
land on, so the limit DNE. (We do sometimes write
\lim_{x \to 0} \tfrac{1}{x^2} = +\infty to describe
how it fails — but "\infty" is not a number, so the
limit still doesn't exist in the ordinary sense.)
3. Endless oscillation
The strangest case: f(x) = \sin\!\left(\frac{1}{x}\right).
As x \to 0 the input \tfrac{1}{x}
races off to infinity, so the sine wiggles between
-1 and 1 faster and faster —
infinitely many times in any tiny interval near 0. The
outputs never home in on a single value, so the limit DNE.
Watch the discontinuities